Online users
???: Message   

Organic chemical (hydroxy sulfide) observed in exoplanet telescopic spectrometer (James Webb).
Post Reply   Forum

Posted by: LateForLunch

09/17/2023, 16:04:08

Author Profile Mail author Edit

If it is what it appears to be, it could likely only be produced by organic means. IOW, the chemical only exists on Earth as a byproduct of homeostasis(life), commonly in oceanic systems.


This is pretty amazing, but still not conclusive because there may be unknown natural INORGANIC chemical processes that could create it. Labs create it by inorganic means all the time but it has never been observed to occur that way in nature.

Also, a single spectrograph reading is not irrefutably reliable.

If they see a very specific isotope of organic chlorophyll consistently in a spectrographic observation like this, that would be damn conclusive. It's a very delicate molecule that is nigh impossible to make in the lab inorganically - relates to plant photosynthesis (the way plants convert sunlight to food).






Modified by LateForLunch at Sun, Sep 17, 2023, 17:18:40


Post Reply | Recommend | Alert View All   Previous | Next | Current page

Replies to this message