|Okay, I see the "what," but I don't get the "why."|
Posted by: TEEBONE ģ |
Author Profile Mail author Edit
Gun Review: Iver Johnson 1911A1 Carbine - The Truth About Guns
Virgil Caldwell for TTAG
I find the 1911 pistol fascinating to a distraction. I have owned most of the makersí works of art. I say that tongue in cheek as I am the first to admit that some arenít all that well made. Some foreign, some domestic, less than service grade in my opinion. The problem is hand-fitting. It must be done. Tight tolerances and expert work are the primary reason a†Guncrafter†or†Wilson Combat†gun costs more than a Colt. Yet the†Colt is a good 1911†by any standard.
Trying to produce a pistol for half the price of a Colt is a daunting proposition. Forged steel frames give way to cast frames and internal parts become MIM rather than machined. This puts the resulting cut rate pistol in the recreational class. Thatís OK as long as you know where you stand.
That said, I know how to maintain, modify and fire a 1911 well. I carry a number of proven 1911 handguns. With the background of my love for the type out of the way lets look at a very interesting piece.
Virgil Caldwell for TTAG
The†Iver Johnson 1911A1 Carbine†isnít a shoulder stocked pistol. I donít want to become acquainted with the folks at Leavenworth. This is a true carbine. The original intent of the shoulder stocked pistol, I believe, was for mounted troops to dismount and fight with a stocked revolver, and sure it wasnít a rifle but it was better than trying to fight a fast moving battle with a rifle on horseback, and then hoping the rifle was still in the scabbard when you dismounted.
The†Luger,†Mauser†and†Browning Hi Power†pistols were often shoulder stock equipped. Adding a stock to a pistol for more stability and accuracy seems like a great ideaÖand it is. Unfortunate, thanks to the National Firearms Act of 1934, there are all kind problems and costs involved with doing that. Mounting a stock on standard pistol makes it a short barrel rifle ó a NFA-regulated item ó in the eyes of the ATF and means youíre in for all kinds of paperwork, not to mention paying for a $200 tax stamp.
So while you canít simply mount a stock on a pistol, there have been attempts at†braces†and†stabilizing kits. I donít know this law well (I would learn if I were interested in this sort of firearm), but I am smart enough not to remove the shoulder stock or change the barrel of this carbine.
In general, a 1911 pistol is for carrying and a Colt 5.56mm carbine is for fighting. A shotgun is for what a shotgun does (which is a lot). The Iver Johnson 1911A1 Carbine is for fun. Generally you canít legally add a shoulder stock a pistol. The Iver Johnson carbine is kind of like the†Rossi Circuit Judge†though the Circuit Judge is a more permanent in configuration. In short, unless you want to open yourself up to potentially nasty interactions with federal regulators, donít change the configuration of the Iver Johnson 1911A1 Carbine for any reason.
The stock is nothing fancyÖjust some texturing for a good mount and the Iver Johnson logo. (Virgil Caldwell for TTAG)
I am not damning the 1911A1 Carbineís stock with faint praise but itís a simple wood plank with a connector. The stock attaches to a polymer mainspring housing and is tightened with a thumbscrew.
The Iver Johnson 1911A1 features a 16.25 inch barrel, making it a legal carbine and letting the seller checks the rifle box on your paperwork. Warning: donít get any bright ideas about subbing out the carbine length barrel with a standard 5-inch 1911 barrel. Again, that way lies NFA sanctions.
Iver Johnson re-brands Philippine-produced†SAM pistols†as the basis of the 1911A1 Carbine. Shooters Arms Manufacturing makes close copies of the standard GI 1911. They have cut a couple of corners, but the pistol comes out well.
Virgil Caldwell for TTAG
The 1911A1 Carbine takes down for cleaning just like a standard 1911 pistol, just be sure you have a longer cleaning rod. The carbine is much like SAMís other pistols. The 1911A1 shows definite improvements in finish and quality over the earlier SAM pistols I tried a decade or so ago and absolutely did not like. A friend of some experience says he now likes them better than the†Rock Island imports. I donít agree, but SAM has made strides and the 1911A1 Carbine is well turned out.
The double diamond wood grips are nice enough and well checkered. The sights are not the abysmal standard rudimentary GI types but slightly improved, taller sights. The trigger breaks at a rather clean 5.0 pounds. It actually improved a little with dry fire. The real surprise ó no obvious burrs, tool marks, and generally high finish with the OD Cerakote finish. This thing looks pretty good.
The Iver Johnson 1911A1ís stock attached to a polymer mainspring housing. (Virgil Caldwell for TTAG)
When you think about it, this wasnít an easy gun to get right. I can imagine the difficulty the engineers had in designing a working pistol that would feed and cycle with the extra weight of a 16.25 inch barrel hanging off of the muzzle end and using the standard swinging link and conventional recoil spring. Lock time and cycle issues must have been a challenge. As far as lock time, cycling, and operation, they got it pretty much right, but it isnít perfect (more on that later).
Most of us could have fabricated the carbineís stock in a high school shop class. Itís has a simple textured curve for shouldering and attaches to the pistol grip with a piece of sheet metal.†The stock has a nineteen inch length of pull, quite a bit longer than most carbines, but comfortable when mounting the gun.
The carbine weighs right at four pounds unloaded, so itís light and maneuverable enough. Even with the 19-inch length of pull, the sights are closer to the eye than is normal with a pistol, which is all good for accuracy.
One thing youíll want to pay attention to is your grip. I found occasional inconsistency in depressing the grip safety. Thereís a small space between the top of the stock mount and the beavertail. Getting a good, consistent grip that depresses the safety and allows the gun to fire takes a little practice.
The carbine isnít difficult to handle, but definitely takes some acclimation for a consistent grip that depresses the grip safety. (Virgil Caldwell for TTAG)
I have a box of forty seven†1911 magazines†I use for range magazines. No the mags I use at the range arenít cheap, but proven magazines that I know work. Thatís my definition of a range†magazine. They include brands like MecGar, Wilson Combat, and Colt.
The Iver Johnson ó which ships with a single 8-round magazine ó locked each of my many mags in place. I first fired the piece with Black Hills Ammunition 200 grain lead semi wadcutters. This is a great load for all-around fun use. Velocity jumped from 870 fps from a five-inch barrel to over 1050 fps from the Iver Johnsonís 16.125-inch tube.
Recoil with stock is very modest, less than a .45 Colt lever action or .410 shotgun. I fired more than a hundred rounds and really enjoyed every shot. I painted the front sight with some nail polish a little later, the only complaint on the first run. I fired a couple of five shot groups at 20 yards. A 1.6-inch group was the best I got, but overall groups were very consistent at 1.6 to 2.0 inches.
Sure a†Springfield TRP†is more accurate, but the Iver Johnson 1911A1 Carbine is cheap and most anyone can get good accuracy out of this firearm right off the bat. It takes some practice to get that type of accuracy from a pistol.
Ball and semi-wad cutters ran flawlessly. JHP ammoÖnot so much. (Virgil Caldwell for TTAG)
The next range session with the newly painted front sight didnít go as well. The carbine simply would not feed†hollow point ammunition.†Not Black Hills with XTP bullets, Hornady XTP, Speer Gold Dots, or Winchesters. Fortunately I had brought some 230 grain RNL handloads and ball ammo so I didnít waste the day.
This is a pistol that youíll need to keep clean. It will slow and eventually stop functioning at between the 200 to 300 round mark if not cleaned and lubricated. Cycling, though, is good. Feed function is not. I am certain I could get the pistol up to speed with a polish job and maybe a bit of modification. Would the next 1911A1 Carbine feed JHP better? Maybe.
On the one hand why bother with the tinkering? This isnít a firearm I would use for critical duty. The darned thing is really just a fun shooter. I think that it wouldnít be the worst home defense carbine using ball ammunition. Loaded with 230 grain ball or the Black Hills 200 grain SWC it would serve pretty well.
Accuracy isnít bad at all either, though not a whole lot better than a good 1911 at distances out the 50 yards. I clocked a couple of 230 grain hollow points by feeding them straight into the chamber. Velocity jumped as much as 170 fps from the carbine length barrel. So what we have here is a nice, low pressure, easy-shooting .45 ACP that delivers more muzzle gee-whiz than a 10mm with very light recoil. The 1911A1 Carbine has grown on me over time. Itís a fun gun to own and shoot as long as you use it within its limitations.
Specifications: Iver Johnson 1911A1 Carbine
Model: 1911A1 Carbine (IJ01RIFLE)
Ratings (out of five stars):
Reliability: * *†
Accuracy: * * * *
Ergonomics: * * *
Fit and Finish: * * *†
Overall: * * *
LIBERTY HAS NO EXPIRATION DATEDemocrats wouldn't buy a clue if it was government subsidized.
|Post Reply | Recommend | Alert||Previous | Next | Current page|